Why Would MASSMutual Professionals Withdraw from their 401(k)s and Delay Social Security Benefits?

In an economic landscape characterized by fluctuating markets, high inflation rates, and complex financial conditions for many MASSMutual professionals, making strategic decisions about retirement savings is crucial. One critical decision centers on when to initiate Social Security benefits. The conventional wisdom advocates for delaying these benefits until reaching the Full Retirement Age (FRA) to maximize the monthly payout. However, this does not always align with the financial realities or strategic considerations individuals must contend with as they approach MASSMutual retirement.

The concept of a 'Social Security bridge' is emerging as a noteworthy strategy, particularly among MASSMutual professionals navigating the transition into retirement. This approach involves a phased retirement income plan that strategically leverages assets from 401(k) plans or similar retirement savings, allowing individuals to postpone claiming Social Security benefits until reaching their FRA, which under current regulations is 70 years old.

Traditionally, the approach involves initiating withdrawals from 401(k) plans at the earliest point they can be made without incurring penalties, typically at age 59 and a half, and limiting these withdrawals to the equivalent of what Social Security benefits would be at age 62, the youngest age at which these benefits can be claimed.

Recent research from the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College underscores the potential advantages of this strategy. The research indicates that individuals might find it beneficial to use their 401(k) assets to bridge the gap until they can claim Social Security benefits, thereby enhancing their eventual monthly payout. The study highlights an increased inclination among participants toward a workplace-sponsored bridging program as they become more informed about it. Implementing a Social Security bridge can provide consistent income, akin to expected lifelong benefit levels, while amplifying those benefits through delayed claiming.

According to data from the Investment Company Institute, as of September 2022, approximately 71 million active participants held 401(k) accounts, with these accounts containing over $6.3 trillion in assets. This substantial pool of retirement savings plays a pivotal role in the current discussion surrounding retirement strategies.

The financial upsides of deferring Social Security benefits are indeed significant. Current stipulations dictate that for every month between the FRA and age 70 that an individual defers claiming Social Security, there is an 8% increase in the eventual monthly benefit for each year of delay. Therefore, an individual reaching their full retirement age at 67 but waiting until 70 to claim benefits would see a 24% increase in their monthly payments.

To illustrate, the breakdown of the maximum monthly benefits for claims made in 2023 is as follows:

• $2,572 for claims at age 62
• $3,627 for claims at the full retirement age (66 and 4 months for individuals born in 1956, 66 and 6 months for those born in 1957)
• $4,555 for claims at age 70

Comparatively, the average Social Security benefit was projected at $1,833 per month as of March 2023. Additionally, beginning in January 2024, Social Security and Supplementary Security Income payments are set to incorporate a 3.2% cost-of-living adjustment.

Despite these financial incentives, deciding to delay benefits is not without psychological and strategic complexities. There exists a significant mental barrier associated with the notion of withdrawing from 401(k) savings prematurely, as these accounts often represent the primary retirement savings mechanism for many individuals. Popular financial commentators like Suze Orman have frequently highlighted the risks associated with early withdrawals from 401(k) accounts before actual retirement.

However, an essential factor to consider is the finite nature of 401(k) savings versus the lifelong structure of Social Security benefits. While there are legitimate concerns regarding the long-term solvency of the Social Security program, using 401(k) assets as a bridge to ensure a larger Social Security benefit can be a prudent strategy. Claiming Social Security at age 70 as opposed to 62 can result in a substantial increase in monthly benefits, a sum that is often competitive with the returns from 401(k) investments, which tend to be more conservatively managed as individuals age.

Social Security offers a degree of stability not commonly associated with 401(k) plans, as the payout remains consistent, with the age of the claimant being the primary variable affecting the benefit amount. However, utilizing a bridging strategy is not without risk. At least 38 states impose taxes on retirement distributions, and individuals intending to use their 401(k) assets for legacy planning may face complex decisions.

Concerns regarding the solvency of the Social Security program, particularly with projections citing potential depletion by 2035, contribute to the hesitancy around delayed claiming. However, experts generally advise against making premature claims based on this apprehension, as legislative measures are likely to be enacted to preserve the program's viability.

Another significant consideration for MASSMutual professionals nearing retirement is the impact of Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) on 401(k) plans. According to the IRS, individuals must start taking RMDs from their retirement accounts at age 72 (as updated in 2020), which could influence the strategy of using 401(k) savings as a Social Security bridge. Notably, RMDs can push retirees into a higher tax bracket, affecting their overall financial planning ('Understanding Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs),' IRS, updated June 2021). Thus, integrating RMDs into the decision-making process is essential when contemplating delaying Social Security benefits.

Given the intricate nature of these decisions, consulting with a financial advisor is often a wise course of action. Data from the Federal Reserve Board indicates that only 40% of non-retirees are confident in their retirement savings, suggesting a significant proportion of MASSMutual professionals could benefit from professional guidance to navigate their financial planning for retirement.

Featured Video

Articles you may find interesting:

With the potential challenges of high inflation and economic downturns, ensuring one's financial security in retirement is paramount. Engaging with a financial advisor through platforms like WiserAdvisor can facilitate access to personalized, expert advice to assist individuals in making informed decisions, investing intelligently, and achieving the retirement they envision. Starting this planning early can prove invaluable, providing peace of mind and a clear roadmap for the journey ahead.