Allstate Retirees Face Rising Premiums: Why 2026 Health Care Costs May Challenge Household Budgets

Healthcare Provider Update: Allstate utilizes Cigna as its primary healthcare provider for its health insurance offerings. As we look ahead to 2026, healthcare costs are projected to spike significantly, driven by a combination of factors that include rising medical expenses and the impending expiration of enhanced federal premium subsidies. Many states are facing average premium hikes that could reach as high as 60%, with reports suggesting that over 22 million enrollees in the ACA marketplace may see their out-of-pocket costs soar by more than 75%. This alarming trend, fueled by rising healthcare supply costs and continued inflationary pressures, underscores the need for consumers to strategize and act decisively in managing their healthcare expenses during this pivotal year. Click here to learn more

“Allstate employees facing rising health care costs can benefit from reviewing their broader income and coverage strategies early given that policy changes may create uncertainty.” – Wesley Boudreaux, a representative of The Retirement Group, a division of Wealth Enhancement.

“Allstate employees navigating potential premium increases may find it helpful to reassess their long-term health care and budget plans early, as preparation can provide clearer direction during periods of policy uncertainty.” – Patrick Ray, a representative of The Retirement Group, a division of Wealth Enhancement.

In this article, we will discuss:

1. How the expiration of enhanced ACA subsidies may affect 2026 premiums.

2. Why many households are delaying enrollment decisions.

3. What retirees and pre-Medicare individuals should consider when reviewing coverage options.

Why Many Americans May Have Trouble Paying 2026 Premiums When Health Care Costs Increase

Households that rely on premium subsidies under the Affordable Care Act are preparing for significant changes. Unless Congress acts, the ACA’s enhanced premium tax credits, extended under the Inflation Reduction Act and expanded by the American Rescue Plan, will expire after the 2025 plan year. If these subsidies lapse, estimates show average net premiums may increase by roughly 75–115% in 2026, ¹  creating financial strain for millions of Americans.

“When a household sees its premium rise dramatically, families can be forced into difficult choices about how to allocate limited income,” explains Wesley Boudreaux, a financial advisor at Wealth Enhancement.

Consumer Uncertainty and Enrollment Pressures

Many Allstate households are delaying their 2026 Marketplace enrollment decisions as they wait to see if Congress will renew the enhanced subsidies. Postponing enrollment increases the risk of missing deadlines and entering the new plan year without coverage.

Some states, such as Pennsylvania, estimate that if subsidies end in 2026, nearly one-third of current enrollees may drop coverage. ²  These estimates reflect affordability concerns, not confirmed enrollment data.

According to Wesley, households are navigating uncertainty rather than disengaging: “Families must make difficult decisions about their health coverage when premiums rise significantly.”

Less Expensive Options May Have Drawbacks

When premiums climb, some Allstate employees may turn to lower-cost alternatives outside the ACA. However, short-term limited duration insurance and other non-ACA-compliant policies often exclude pre-existing conditions, impose annual or lifetime limits, and may not include guaranteed comprehensive benefits. These gaps may leave individuals exposed to significant medical bills during serious illness.

“Lower premiums only matter if the coverage is there when you need it,” Wesley emphasizes. Many non-ACA policies lack essential health benefits and pre-existing condition protections.

Challenging Decisions for Important Groups

If subsidies are not renewed, households may find themselves evaluating difficult choices:

• - Moving to ACA plans with higher deductibles

• - Paying substantially more in premiums

• - Dropping coverage entirely

• - Considering non-ACA options with limited protections

Middle-class families, self-employed individuals, and pre-Medicare retirees may feel the greatest financial pressure if enhanced subsidies disappear.

“Many responsible, hardworking families are severely strained by large premium increases,” observes Wesley.

The Function of Subsidies in a Changing Market

Many households currently benefit from subsidies that may reduce premiums by hundreds of dollars each month. If enhanced subsidies expire, out-of-pocket expenses could increase sharply. Insurers have already priced 2026 plans based on current law, contributing to the “sticker shock” consumers are experiencing, even if Congress ultimately restores subsidies.

In this unsettled environment, reviewing coverage options and planning ahead becomes even more important.

How The Retirement Group Can Assist

For individuals not yet eligible for Medicare—including those leaving the Allstate workforce—health care costs remain a major part of retirement planning.

The Retirement Group can help you review your health insurance choices in the context of your broader retirement income strategy.
Call (800) 900-5867  to speak with someone about preparing for rising health care expenses.

Create a Plan Before Policies Change Again

Marketplace premiums for 2026 reflect a combination of insurer cost increases and legislative uncertainty, and future health care policies may continue evolving. Thoughtful preparation can help households reduce the likelihood of coverage gaps and build a clearer understanding of the alternatives available to them.

Featured Video

Articles you may find interesting:

Sources:

1. Peterson-KFF. ' How much and why ACA Marketplace premiums are going up in 2026 ,' by J. Ortaliza et al. Aug. 6, 2025. 

2. The Hospital and Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania.  “5 Things to Know: Pennie Open Enrollment.”  HAP Blog , 30 Oct. 2025,  www.haponline.org/News/HAP-News-Articles/HAP-Blog/5-things-to-know-pennie-open-enrollment-1 .

Other Resources:

1. Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.  “Five Key Changes to ACA Marketplaces Amid Uncertainty over Premium Tax Credit Enhancements.”  Written by Jennifer Sullivan and Nicole Rapfogel, 22 Sept. 2025,  www.cbpp.org/research/health/five-key-changes-to-aca-marketplaces-amid-uncertainty-over-premium-tax-credit .

2. Evans, Michael.  “2026 Health Insurance Hike Sparks Concern Among Early Retirees: ‘We Cannot Afford This.’”  Investopedia , 12 Sept. 2025,  www.investopedia.com/2026-health-insurance-hike-sparks-concern-among-early-retirees-we-cannot-afford-this-11808938 .

3. KFF.  “Calculator: ACA Enhanced Premium Tax Credit.”  KFF, 29 Oct. 2025,  www.kff.org/interactive/calculator-aca-enhanced-premium-tax-credit/ .

4. United States Departments of the Treasury, Labor, and Health and Human Services.  “Short-Term, Limited-Duration Insurance.”  Federal Register , 21 Feb. 2018,  www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/02/21/2018-03208/short-term-limited-duration-insurance .