Maximizing Your Returns: Advanced Strategies for Maturing CDs as a TIAA Employee

Investors at TIAA have enjoyed a period of rising yields on certificates of deposit (CDs) as returns have hit 5%, leading to trillions of dollars being injected into these secure investment instruments. However, with a significant portion of these funds maturing soon, there is a potential risk that needs to be understood: reinvesting at lower interest rates, which could diminish overall returns.

CDs are favored because they offer a fixed interest rate for a determined period, generally from one month to five years or more. Market volatility and economic uncertainty have prompted many to seek the security of CDs, especially after yields reached attractive levels over the past year. Currently, CDs with durations of less than one year are offering annual percentage yields (APYs) between 5% and 5.5%, significantly higher than many other conservative products.

According to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), this demand has led to a record $2.9 trillion held in CDs.  However, the fact that many are invested in short-term CDs means that nearly $2.5 trillion will mature in the next year, and about $950 billion of this sum will mature in the next three months at TIAA.

As these CDs mature, TIAA investors will need to make decisions that could impact their future earnings. Financial professional James White advises CD holders to be cautious with their reinvestment strategies. A critical risk is the possibility of the bank automatically reinvesting funds, often in CDs at much lower rates than the initial terms. Moreover, anticipated actions by the Federal Reserve, such as lowering interest rates, could further reduce the returns available on new CDs.

Be wary of stock rotations.

When a CD matures, it might seem convenient to let the bank automatically roll it over into a new one. However, this can be risky, especially if the bank offers a lower yield than expected. Sometimes, banks might transfer funds to products with interest rates far below leading offers, particularly when clients do not actively monitor their accounts. For example, the national average for a 12-month CD is currently under 2%, according to FDIC data, which is significantly lower than the top offers of over 5%.

Before allowing a transfer, it is crucial to review the terms of the new CD to aid in a competitive offer. Banks often wish to retain client funds and may be willing to negotiate higher rates, especially if the client holds multiple accounts with the institution. Financial professionals recommend contacting the bank and requesting that they match the best rates available on the market at TIAA.

Locking in Rates with Longer-Term CDs

Given the Federal Reserve's announcement to begin reducing short-term interest rates, it might be timely to lock in higher rates with a long-term CD. Wall Street analysts suggest that the federal funds rate, which significantly influences credit rates, could decrease by more than 2 percentage points in the coming year. For investors who can afford to tie up their money for an extended period, it may be wise to set up a three- or five-year CD at current rates.

Today, the highest rates for three-year CDs range from 4.5% to 4.7%, while five-year CDs offer rates from 4.2% to 4.5%, according to DepositAccounts data . These rates provide a shield against the possibility of interest rate declines in the near future, helping that investors shield their current interest rates for a longer period at TIAA.

For those hesitant to allocate all their funds to long-term CDs, a strategy called 'CD laddering' might be a solution. A CD ladder involves dividing investments into small amounts and staggering maturity dates. This way, investors can benefit from both short-term liquidity and long-term fixed rates. For instance, it's possible to invest in CDs with maturities ranging from six months to two years, and as each CD matures, the funds can be reinvested or accessed as needed.

Exploring Treasury Bonds as an Alternative

For TIAA employees looking for an alternative to CDs, treasury bonds offer another investment option. Although the yields on three-year treasury bonds are currently around 3.8%, lower than CDs, they offer other benefits. Treasury bonds are backed by the U.S. government and provide a fixed interest rate until maturity, similar to CDs. But unlike CDs, they can be sold on the secondary market before the contract ends if the investor needs liquidity.

One advantage of treasury bonds is that they can increase in value if interest rates fall. Stock prices move inversely to interest rates, meaning that when rates decrease, the value of existing higher-interest securities increases. This dynamic can provide a valuable opportunity for investors to sell bonds at a higher price if necessary.

In addition to individual treasury bonds, investors might also consider treasury-exchanged funds (ETFs). For example, the iShares 3-7 Year Treasury Bond ETF offers a yield of 3.7%. Over the past year, this ETF has generated a total return of 6.8%, including both yields and price increases. While this return is higher than many current CD offerings, it's essential to remember that treasury bonds exhibit some price volatility, and selling before maturity can result in a loss if market conditions change.

Featured Video

Articles you may find interesting:

The Importance of Monitoring Federal Reserve Movements

As the Federal Reserve moves towards a more accommodative monetary policy, this will significantly impact exchange rates and bond yields. Anticipating Fed rate cuts could reduce the yields on new CDs and treasury bonds, making it crucial for investors to take steps now to gain potential higher rates. By using a long-term CD or treasury bond, investors can shield their portfolios from the anticipation of falling interest rates.

It is also vital to stay informed about bank policies regarding savings credits, as some of these policies can sometimes harm investors who are not attentive to the proposed conditions. Most banks will seek to transfer funds to low-yield products, and it is up to the investor to claim their investment provides the best possible return at TIAA.

In conclusion.

Due to the upcoming maturity of a large portion of CDs, investors are faced with a critical moment to make decisions. Whether to reinvest in CDs, shield rates with long-term options, or explore other options such as treasury securities, it is essential to stay proactive in managing investments. Observing interest rate fluctuations and being attentive to bank terms will help prudent reinvestment of funds, thereby reducing the risk of locking in lower incomes during a period of falling interest rates.

By leveraging current market conditions and exploring all available opportunities, investors can make informed decisions that will preserve and grow their wealth over the long term.

According to a recent study by AARP (2023), retirees should consider the impact of required minimum distributions (RMDs) from their retirement accounts when reinvesting matured CDs . RMDs, which start at age 73, can push retirees into higher income brackets, reducing the overall benefit of reinvesting in low-interest-rate CDs. One strategy is to explore tax-efficient investment options such as municipal bonds, which offer tax-exempt income and can help manage tax liability. It is crucial to stay informed about tax implications when reinvesting to optimize profits and be knowledgeable of unexpected financial burdens.(AARP, June 2023).

It's akin to navigating a ship through changing storms. When waters are calm and interest rates are high, it's possible to sail smoothly and potentially gain favorable returns. However, as the sea shifts to declining rates, maintaining your pace requires meticulous adjustments. If you're not careful, your vessel may sink into low-yield waters, diminishing your profits. To keep your wealth growing, it's essential to make strategic decisions—whether by locking in long-term rates or exploring other investments—to gain confidence that your savings remain stable, even during uncertain times.

The information is not intended as a recommendation. The opinions are subject to change at any time and no forecasts can be guaranteed. Investment decisions should always be made based on an investor's specific circumstances. Investing involves risk including possible loss of principal.