New Update: Healthcare Costs Increasing by Over 60% in Some States. Will you be impacted?

Caterpillar Employees: Should You Delay Your RMD When the S&P 500 Is Down?

Caterpillar employees should carefully time their Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) to avoid selling assets at reduced prices during market downturns, as strategic withdrawal planning can help preserve future portfolio growth and minimize unnecessary tax burdens. – Michael Corgiat, a representative of The Retirement Group, a division of Wealth Enhancement Group.

Caterpillar employees should consider the impact of market volatility on their RMD strategies, as delaying withdrawals during market downturns can allow for potential recovery, helping to protect long-term retirement assets and minimize tax exposure. – Brent Wolf, a representative of The Retirement Group, a division of Wealth Enhancement Group.

In this article, we will discuss:

Impact of market fluctuations on RMD timing strategies
Differences between RMDs and Roth IRA conversions
Portfolio composition and tax-efficient approaches for Caterpillar retirees

Navigating RMDs Amid Market Volatility

Market fluctuations can complicate income planning for retirees relying on distributions from retirement accounts. As of 2025, the IRS requires individuals aged 73 and older to take annual RMDs from tax-deferred accounts like 401(k)s and traditional IRAs. The RMD amount is calculated based on the account balance as of December 31 of the previous year, divided by a life expectancy factor provided by the IRS. Younger Caterpillar retirees, while not subject to RMDs, may still need to make withdrawals to cover living expenses.

Historically, many have delayed their RMDs until year-end to better assess their annual income and potentially minimize tax implications. Others opt for monthly or quarterly distributions. However, with current market volatility affecting major indices like the Dow Jones Industrial Average, Nasdaq, and S&P 500, the timing of these withdrawals has become more consequential.

Challenges of Fixed RMD Calculations During Market Downturns

A key issue is that RMD calculations are based on the account value at the end of the previous year and do not adjust for market declines that may occur afterward. For instance, if a retiree's IRA was valued at $850,000 on December 31, 2024, their 2025 RMD would be approximately $33,000. If the market value drops to $790,000 by April 2025, the retiree is still obligated to withdraw the full $33,000, potentially requiring the sale of more shares at reduced prices.

Pam Krueger, founder of Wealthramp, highlights this predicament: Selling assets at reduced prices to meet a withdrawal requirement based on a higher previous value can be a double-edged sword.

Distinguishing Between RMDs and Roth IRA Conversions

A common misconception is treating RMDs and Roth IRA conversions similarly. While converting funds from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA during market lows can be advantageous due to tax-free growth potential, RMDs involve mandatory withdrawals that are taxed and, if reinvested, may be subject to capital gains taxes.

George Gagliardi, a certified financial adviser in Massachusetts, advises handling RMDs and Roth conversions as separate strategies. He suggests using more stable assets, like short-term bonds, for RMDs to minimize the impact of market volatility, while reserving assets with higher growth potential for Roth conversions.

Importance of Portfolio Composition

The structure of a retirement portfolio significantly influences RMD strategies. Diversified portfolios typically include a mix of cash, bonds, stocks, and short-term securities. Rob Williams, managing director of financial planning at Schwab, emphasizes viewing the portfolio as a collection of distinct assets rather than a single entity.

Portfolios with low-volatility assets, such as Treasury bonds or short-term CDs, can provide liquidity for RMDs without necessitating the sale of equities during downturns. Implementing bond ladders with staggered maturity dates can help align asset availability with RMD schedules.

Considerations for Inherited IRAs

Inherited IRAs present additional complexities. Non-spouse beneficiaries are required to deplete the account within ten years, with RMDs enforced throughout this period. All distributions are taxed as ordinary income. B Capital

Scott Bishop, a Texas-based money manager, encountered a client contemplating early withdrawals from an inherited IRA due to market declines. He suggests a hybrid approach: withdrawing funds (after taxes) and reinvesting them in a taxable brokerage account. This strategy may result in future gains being taxed at lower capital gains rates, potentially reducing the overall tax burden.

Timing RMDs Strategically

While market volatility adds complexity to RMD timing, thoughtful planning remains essential. Since the RMD amount is fixed based on the previous year's account value, retirees have the opportunity to choose when to take distributions. Delaying withdrawals can allow for potential market recovery and defer associated taxes.

Pam Krueger advises against hastily selling assets during market lows, suggesting that waiting can provide both tax deferral and the chance for account value recovery.

Final Thoughts

In uncertain markets, it's important to resist impulsive decisions. The approach to accessing retirement funds—whether through RMDs, inherited IRA withdrawals, or broader income strategies—should focus on minimizing losses and maintaining portfolio value. For Caterpillar retirees, this means adopting a methodical approach to withdrawals, utilizing diversified portfolios with components like cash reserves, short-term bonds, and strategically structured ladders to meet distribution needs without compromising future growth.

A Vanguard report from December 2023 indicates that taking RMDs later in the year has historically correlated with higher average portfolio values, as markets often recover from mid-year volatility. In years with presidential elections, the S&P 500 has averaged gains of 7.3% in the second half, suggesting that postponing RMDs may provide more favorable conditions for asset sales.

Analogy

Withdrawing your RMD during a market downturn is akin to selling your home during a housing slump because you must relocate; you may receive less than if you had waited for the market to rebound. By carefully timing withdrawals, retirees can retain more of their investment assets, similar to homeowners waiting for a seller's market. This is especially pertinent when mandatory distributions are based on higher account values from the previous year, regardless of current performance.

Featured Video

Articles you may find interesting:

Source:

1. Royal, James. How Required Minimum Distributions Impact Your Traditional IRA Balance. Investopedia , 15 Apr. 2025, www.investopedia.com/required-minimum-distributions-ira-impact-5185475 .

2. Riquier, Andrea. Should I Rush to Take My RMD While the S&P 500 Is Down, or Wait Until the End of the Year Like Normal? MarketWatch , 12 Apr. 2025, www.marketwatch.com/rmd-timing-strategy-s-p-500-2025-5183472 .

3. RMD Strategies to Help Ease Your Tax Burden. Charles Schwab , Jan. 2025, www.schwab.com/rmd-tax-strategy-planning-2025 .

4. Inherited IRAs: What to Know About Taxes, RMDs, and More. Morningstar , Mar. 2025, www.morningstar.com/inherited-iras-rmd-tax-implications-2025 .

5. RMD Strategies for Wealthy Retirees: 2025 Tax Planning Guide. RCS Planning , Mar. 2025, www.rcsplanning.com/rmd-strategies-tax-planning-wealthy-retirees-2025 .

How does the transition from the Solar Plan to the Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan impact current or former employees of Caterpillar Inc. in terms of retirement benefits and service credits? Considering both plans' differences, what aspects should employees of Caterpillar Inc. understand to ensure they are maximizing their retirement benefits under this merged structure?

Transition from Solar Plan to Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan: The transition from the Solar Plan to the Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan maintained the benefits of those previously covered under the Solar Plan without impact. Both plans allowed the continuation of prior service credits and the incorporation of benefits payable under previous retirement plans. For current or former employees, understanding the nuances of how prior service credits and benefits are integrated can maximize their retirement benefits under the merged structure.

What specific criteria must Caterpillar Inc. employees meet to qualify for early retirement and what implications does this have on their pension benefits? For employees planning early retirement, what calculations or benefit reductions should they be prepared for according to Caterpillar Inc.â€™s policies?

Criteria for Early Retirement at Caterpillar Inc.: Employees wishing to take early retirement must meet specific age and service requirements detailed in the plan documents. For early retirement, benefits calculations and potential reductions are significant. Employees need to prepare for possible reductions in their pension benefits depending on their age and years of credited service at retirement.

In the context of the Pension Equity Plan (PEP) and the Traditional Pension Plan, how do the benefit calculations differ for employees at Caterpillar Inc., particularly for those who switched from the Traditional Plan to the PEP? What considerations should current Caterpillar Inc. employees take into account when evaluating which plan may offer them more secure benefits?

Differences Between PEP and Traditional Pension Plan: The benefit calculations for the Pension Equity Plan (PEP) and the Traditional Pension Plan differ significantly. PEP calculates a lump sum based on salary and years of service, while the Traditional Plan calculates benefits based on final earnings or credited service formulas. Employees need to consider which plan offers more secure benefits based on their individual career trajectory and earnings history.

What steps must Caterpillar Inc. employees take to ensure that their Credited Service is accurately calculated and maintained throughout their employment, especially in light of the company's policies regarding breaks in service? How might phases of employment, such as parental leave or temporary positions, affect this calculation?

Credited Service Calculation and Maintenance: To ensure accurate credited service calculation, employees must maintain thorough records and communicate any changes in employment status, such as breaks in service or changes in personal information, to the plan administrator. Understanding the rules for service credits during different phases of employment, such as parental leave or temporary positions, is crucial.

How can employees at Caterpillar Inc. file a claim for benefits under the retirement plans, and what are the essential details they need to provide to ensure their claims are processed smoothly? If they encounter issues or denials, what recourse do they have within the Caterpillar Inc. system to appeal these decisions?

Filing a Claim for Benefits: Employees should provide detailed and accurate information when filing a claim for benefits under the retirement plans. If issues or denials occur, they have the right to appeal these decisions. Familiarity with the claims procedure and required documentation can streamline this process.

For employees approaching retirement, what resources are available through Caterpillar Inc. to help them navigate the complexities of their retirement benefits? What steps should an employee take if they wish to understand their benefits better or need assistance with retirement planning?

Resources for Navigating Retirement Benefits: Caterpillar Inc. offers resources to assist employees in navigating the complexities of their retirement benefits. Employees approaching retirement should utilize these resources and may need to engage with the company's human resources or benefits departments for personalized assistance.

What are the implications of the changes to the cash-out limit for de minimis benefits at Caterpillar Inc., which will take effect after December 31, 2023? How does this change affect employees who may have a vested interest in understanding their financial benefit options upon termination or retirement?

Implications of Cash-Out Limit Changes: The increase in the cash-out limit for de minimis benefits affects how small vested benefits are processed upon termination or retirement. Employees with small benefit amounts should understand how these changes may impact their options and tax implications.

How does Caterpillar Inc. ensure that its pension benefits are protected from creditors, and what specific provisions exist to safeguard these benefits? Moreover, how do legal instruments like Qualified Domestic Relations Orders (QDROs) interact with Caterpillar Inc.'s benefits system for employees undergoing divorce?

Protection of Pension Benefits from Creditors: Caterpillar Inc.'s retirement plans are designed with protections to safeguard benefits from creditors, including adherence to Qualified Domestic Relations Orders (QDROs) during instances like divorce. Employees should understand how these legal instruments can affect their retirement savings.

In what ways does the Caterpillar Inc. Retirement Income Plan provide coverage for disability retirement, and how is this benefit calculated for employees? What factors influence eligibility and how do employees initiate claims if they find themselves in need of these benefits?

Disability Retirement Coverage: The plan provides specific provisions for disability retirement, including how benefits are calculated and eligibility criteria. Employees should be aware of how disability affects their benefits and the process for initiating claims if needed.

How can Caterpillar Inc. employees contact the company to learn more about their retirement benefits, and what information should they have ready when making inquiries? Additionally, what specific departments at Caterpillar Inc. should employees reach out to for the most efficient assistance regarding their retirement plan questions?

Contacting the Company for Retirement Benefit Information: Employees can contact the Caterpillar Benefits Center for inquiries about their retirement benefits. Knowing the specific departments to contact for efficient assistance is crucial for addressing concerns and making informed decisions about retirement planning.